Contesting a Will
American law starts from testamentary freedom: people may leave their property to whom they choose, and being treated unfairly is not by itself a ground to challenge a will. Successful contests turn on how the will was made — capacity, undue influence, formalities, fraud — rather than on how it turned out. Deadlines once probate opens are short. Call 1-844-690-0555 free, any hour — and a one-hour consultation with a licensed US attorney ($195, a fixed fee) can be booked right on the call.
Free legal information, 24/7. Speak to a real lawyer about your situation, any time.
Once probate is opened and notice is given, the window to contest is short — in many states a matter of months, and in some far less. If you are considering a challenge, get advice as soon as you learn probate has opened, not after assets are distributed.
Contesting a Will at a glance
The grounds that actually succeed
Testamentary capacity is assessed at the moment of signing: did the person understand they were making a will, roughly what they owned, and who would normally expect to inherit. A dementia diagnosis does not automatically defeat a will, and a lucid interval can be enough. Undue influence is coercion that overbore the person's free will — the classic pattern being a beneficiary who isolated the person, controlled access, arranged the lawyer and received a sudden change in their favour. Improper execution is the technical ground that quietly wins cases: wrong number of witnesses, witnesses who were also beneficiaries, missing signature formalities. Talk it through with a lawyer now →Spouses and children have separate protections
A surviving spouse in most states cannot simply be disinherited: elective share statutes let them claim a percentage of the estate regardless of the will, and community property states treat marital property as half theirs already. Some states protect a spouse and minor children with homestead and family allowance rights that take priority over the will. Children who are unintentionally omitted — for instance born after the will was made — have protection in most states as pretermitted heirs, but a child deliberately and clearly disinherited generally has no claim at all. Talk it through with a lawyer now →No-contest clauses and the risk calculation
Many wills include a clause providing that anyone who challenges forfeits whatever they were left. States differ sharply: some enforce them strictly, many decline to enforce where the challenge was brought with probable cause, and a few do not enforce them at all. The practical effect is a real risk calculation — challenging a will that leaves you something, in a state that enforces the clause, can cost you what you had. Get advice on your state's rule before filing anything, and consider whether the evidence is strong enough to justify the exposure. Talk it through with a lawyer now →If you want to challenge a will, step by step
Contesting a Will — your questions answered
Can I contest a will just because it is unfair?
No. Unfairness is not a ground — people are entitled to leave their property as they wish. You need a legal ground such as lack of capacity, undue influence, improper execution or fraud, and you need standing, meaning you would inherit under a prior will or under intestacy if the challenge succeeded. Start by getting the will, the prior will if there is one, and the drafting file.
Can my spouse disinherit me?
In most states, not entirely. Elective share statutes allow a surviving spouse to claim a percentage of the estate regardless of what the will says, and in community property states half of the marital property is already yours. There are deadlines for making the election, and they are short, so this is a claim to raise promptly rather than to think about.
What is a no-contest clause?
A provision that disinherits anyone who challenges the will. Whether it works depends entirely on your state: some enforce them, many refuse to where the challenge had probable cause, and a few ignore them altogether. Because the downside is losing what you were actually left, this is the first thing to check before filing a contest — and it is a state-specific question.
Not sure where you stand? Find out in minutes.
Call the free hotline any time. We'll help you understand your options and, if you need one, connect you with a lawyer — anywhere in Australia, usually within the hour.
Call now — 1-844-690-0555Free legal information. Not legal advice.